HiRez Poll Steely Dan - GAUCHO [DVD-A/SACD]

JonUrban · Oct 17, 2004

Please post your comments, thoughts and observations.......

(Since this is a "HiRez" poll, it should not include how you feel about the DTS CD, however you can post your feelings comparing the DTS with the SACD/DVD-A)

SACD scans:

DVD-A/V scans:

MIDIQ · Oct 17, 2004

I have this one on DTS CD, and it is just fantastic. I gave it a 10, great songs and great surround mix, a must have for me. I can't see any reason to upgrade to the DVD-A or SACD, this one sounds superb to me in DTS CD.

bobou2 · Oct 18, 2004

Well I have all 3 surround versions of this great album.
My SACD developed cracks within 3 weeks of purchase so I had to buy the DVD-A when that came out, but I had the 563a so no play until upgrade.
IMHO the DVD-a has a better drum sound, everthing else sounds the same.

Now, the DTS cd mix is different beast....It has some drums(My Rivial) that are on all of the stereo versions but are missing from the new 5:1 mixes. It sticks out like a sore-thumb to me. But I hardly play the DTS version.

I'm still giving this release a 10...and IMHO there is no major difference between the SACD/DVD-A....except for the cracks ; )

blackbirdr · Oct 21, 2004

Where is the AJA 5.1 mix. I also own all three MC mixes. sacd sits on the side since it does no play in my Acura.

kumquad · Jul 10, 2005

I have the SACD version, (I bought the DVD-A, but no play on my 563a) and thought the sonics and mix to very good to excellent. Lower score because this isn't a great Steely Dan LP, much rather have Aja or Katy Lied in surround.

kumquad

Frantic · Jul 14, 2005

Great on DVD-A

The only reason I gave it a 9 rating was because of the lack of extras.

Rudy · Oct 24, 2005

Not my favorite SD album, but better than the two recent ones. Predictable surround mix, but not bad. It gets an 8 from me.

Chris Gerhard · Mar 1, 2006

This album is the biggest improvement I have observed from CD to DVD-A. Surround mix is great and music very good, a solid 9 for me. I don't plan on buying many high resolution surround recordings of music I am so familiar with but this is one that was worth it for me.

Chris

aquadad · Mar 1, 2006

MIDIQ said:
I have this one on DTS CD, and it is just fantastic. I gave it a 10, great songs and great surround mix, a must have for me. I can't see any reason to upgrade to the DVD-A or SACD, this one sounds superb to me in DTS CD.

I second your emotion!

CPR · Mar 2, 2006

I have the DVD-A
One of the best I've ever heard
A must for all!

buc18 · Jan 21, 2007

All of the Steely Dan/Fagen discs get high marks from me and this is no exception. This one has a soft spot in my heart as it was the first DVD-A that I bought and thus my intro into hi rez surround. I wasn't disappointed. A 10!

budlyte · Jun 4, 2007

Just picked up the DVD-A last month. Too bad I waited so long. It sounds incredible!

slowspeed · Oct 16, 2007

Masterpiece.10

neil wilkes · Oct 18, 2007

One word summary.
Beautiful.
I only got this one recently, and my sole regret is that I didn't buy it earlier.

umrk · Dec 23, 2007

I was a bit disappointed with my SACD version compared to my regular 16 bit copy.

The SACD doesn't sound that much better. Just a little less grainy.

I always thought that the regular 16 bit version was a good example of how good a well made CD could sound.

I qualify this comment by saying that I use a good quality CD player but only a modest priced SACD player.

timbre4 · Dec 23, 2007

The DVD-A is very smooth; not the best I've ever heard but no regrets. The old DTS CD was pretty good for what it was in it's day but this is the rest of the sound we always knew was there.

hafquark · Jan 1, 2008

I'd say about 8 to 9 for the music, and a 10 for the audio and surround mix. It's pretty much a reference quality DVD-A to show off your 5.1 setup.

bmoura · Jan 1, 2008

umrk said:
I was a bit disappointed with my SACD version compared to my regular 16 bit copy.

The SACD doesn't sound that much better. Just a little less grainy.

I always thought that the regular 16 bit version was a good example of how good a well made CD could sound.

I qualify this comment by saying that I use a good quality CD player but only a modest priced SACD player.

Hmm, must be the SACD player. Listening to Gaucho here in Super Audio CD surround, it's excellent!

fzappa · May 27, 2008

One of those discs I reserve a 10 for. I have the DVDa. Definitely one to be used for demo'ing your system.

leevitalone1 · May 29, 2008

a keeper. I have yet to hear the sacd or dts but this was very well thought out. I have all the dvd-audio stuff that the dan put out and all of fagens solo stuff on HR. I'm extremly pleased with this stuff. from a tape master to almost perfection, with no audible noise that was always there in older formats. I remember my 1st cd player , I had "Abbey Road" you could hear the tape start ( hiss). but now all this stuff from the 70's sounds sooo nice!

HiRez Poll Steely Dan - GAUCHO [DVD-A/SACD]

Help Support QuadraphonicQuad:

Rate the DVD-A/SACD of Steely Dan - GAUCHO

10: A Classic Disc - A must have!

9:

8:

7:

6:

5:

4:

3:

2: Forget it, Get the CD

1: Waste of plastic

Forum Curmudgeon

600 Club - QQ All-Star

Senior Member

Member

Member

701 Club - QQ All-Star

Active Member

2K Club - QQ Super Nova

400 Club - QQ All-Star

500 Club - QQ All-Star

Active Member

Member

New member

2K Club - QQ Super Nova

Member

Administrator

400 Club - QQ All-Star

2K Club - QQ Super Nova

Active Member

2K Club - QQ Super Nova

Similar threads