HiRez Poll America - HOMECOMING [DVD-A/SACD]

JonUrban · Nov 14, 2004

Please post your thoughts and comments on this 5.1 surround release from Warner/Rhino, issued on DVD-A in September 2001 and later reissued as an SACD by Audio Fidelity in 2015. When posting comments, please indicate what format you are commenting on.

NOTE: Comments prior to Post #55 were made prior to the SACD being released, so they obviously are directed towards the DVD-A.

===================================================

MIDIQ · Nov 14, 2004

Fantastic music and fantastic surround mix. A must have. 10. :sun

Cai Campbell · Nov 15, 2004

Everything about this disc shines! I have a feeling its score is going to suffer here since America doesn't get a lot of respect for their music. I always kind of liked America but really didn't pay much attention beyond their radio airplay until I picked up this disc. They certainly earned my respect. This one's a keeper!

winopener · Nov 15, 2004

I like America ad this is my favorite lp of them, so no suprise for a full 10/10.
Excellent surround mix but... where is the dts track?

EMB · Nov 22, 2004

From an artistic standpoint, would have preferred their far superior debut..but very nice, balanced, detailed sound, pleasing selection of songs, and anyway, better in that regard than the less consistent efforts to come. A '9'...

ED

mrtanner · Nov 22, 2004

I gave it a 9. The track, "Only In Your Heart" has good sound. The rest of the disk is unbelievable! You won't believe this recording is 30 years old.

JonUrban · Nov 22, 2004

I wish Rhino would have given us the rest of their early albums. Hearts and Holiday were mainstream Quad releases and could have been dusted off very easily. However, if we were only to get one, it's nice that it was one that was NOT previously available in surround, as we can always listen to the original QLPs, Reels and Q8's of the 2 quad titles.

ChristopherLees · Nov 23, 2004

I.M.O this is the best lp that America ever did.
It's great from start to finish.
Listening to it makes you wish for a multichannel dvda of their first self titled lp "America" as well..
and the quad reels of Hearts and Holiday are great too..

and why do all of their warner brothers lp's (except the first self titled one ) start with the letter H?

Homecoming
Hatrick
Holiday
Hearts
History
Hideaway
Harbour

JonUrban · Nov 23, 2004

That was done on purpose. Their first LP, although it appeared originally without this track, was subsequently subtitled "Horse with No Name".

Cai Campbell · Nov 23, 2004

This album went from being an ignored America album to my very favorite, after listening to the DVD-A a few times. I agree; wonderful album from start to finish.

Bob Romano · Nov 23, 2004

One of my most played discs! I can hear "To Each His Own" over and over again. Beautiful songs - great mix. A definite 10 from me.

Eggplant · Nov 30, 2004

This is my favorite DVD-A. A solid 10.

The 5.1 mixes are as good as they come. Unbeatable for emotionally involving surround, and that's what it's all about for me.

Best track: Saturn nights. Better than drugs.

Another standout: Everyone I meet is from California (original title) -- arguably the best of the three versions they recorded of this, the peak Peek composition.

Guy Robinson · Nov 30, 2004

Eggplant · Dec 4, 2004

JonUrban said:
That was done on purpose. Their first LP, although it appeared originally without this track, was subsequently subtitled "Horse with No Name".

Don't forget their 1979 release, "Silent Letter".

winopener · Dec 4, 2004

Bidkat said:
Don't forget their 1979 release, "Silent Letter".

))
BTW, nice album but i like a lot more the follower, "Alibi" - and i liked it a lot back when it came out in 1980, not in 1982 when it became a top seller and shot to n.1 on the italian charts. This is an album i would really love to have in 5.1, there's no weak song on the entire album. Too bad America had been treated very badly in the last decades (try to get a complete cd discography...).

eelkiller · Dec 16, 2004

Love the album, California revisited is one of my favorite tunes by the band. I gave it an 8

Eggplant · Dec 17, 2004

eelkiller said:
California revisited is one of my favorite tunes by the band.

That's the song I meant. It's known as "Everyone I Meet is from California" in its two other versions, first as the rare B-side of "Horse With No Name" and a remake on the 1991 Rhino collection. One of their best, no doubt. Possibly Dan Peek's greatest contribution.

winopener · Dec 18, 2004

Bidkat said:
That's the song I meant. It's known as "Everyone I Meet is from California" in its two other versions, first as the rare B-side of "Horse With No Name" and a remake on the 1991 Rhino collection. One of their best, no doubt. Possibly Dan Peak's greatest contribution.

I don't know the 1991 Rhino version, however there's another version on he 1994 album "hourglass" released by American Gramaphone. Check it out, it's worthy.

Felix E. Martinez · Apr 15, 2006

I was introduced to this album by the DVD-A. Can you imagine? Amazing album and 5.1 mix. Highly recommended!

bliss_band · Jul 1, 2006

You guys are all selling this one really well. I'm gonna order it SOON!

HiRez Poll America - HOMECOMING [DVD-A/SACD]

Help Support QuadraphonicQuad:

Rate the DVD-A/SACD of America - HOMECOMING

10 - Excellent Surround, Excellent Fidelity, Excellent Content

9:

8:

7:

6:

5:

4:

3:

2:

1 - Poor Surround, Poor Fidelity, Poor Contact

Forum Curmudgeon

600 Club - QQ All-Star

In Remembrance

2K Club - QQ Super Nova

2K Club - QQ Super Nova

Active Member

Forum Curmudgeon

2K Club - QQ Super Nova

Forum Curmudgeon

In Remembrance

Administrator

1K Club - QQ Shooting Star

2K Club - QQ Super Nova

1K Club - QQ Shooting Star

2K Club - QQ Super Nova

Active Member

1K Club - QQ Shooting Star

2K Club - QQ Super Nova

300 Club - QQ All-Star

Active Member

Similar threads