I never followed Fish beyond his Marillion days. If this is representative of what the back catalog is like, I'm going to have to buy more of it. Any Fish aficionados out there who want to advise on where this falls in the Fish cannon and recommendations for where to go next?
The majority of the devoted seem to be holding this in high regard. Top 2 or 3. To me, there may be some sentimentality to that as it is supposed to be his last studio album.
If you like the overall feeling of this album, I would say try
Raingods with Zippos (1999) &
A Feast of Consequences (2013) which I feel both have the same type of proggy, prose to music vein.
Personally, I like more of a neo-prog style and feel that his debut,
Vigil in a Wilderness of Mirrors (1990) is his best. Essentially it consists of a lot of lyrical ideas he was working on before leaving Marillion. Highlights for me are
The Company ,
Cliché with an awesome Hal Lindes solo, and his best ballad "
A Gentleman's Excuse Me".
The follow-up
Internal Exile (1991) tries hard to follow up on the debut and there are three really strong songs
Shadowplay,
Internal Exile, &
Credo (which you would likely love if you found songs like
Assassing from
Fugazi to your liking. The rest of the album cuts have more of modern AOR vibe of the day.
Suits (1994) can't seem to find itself. It is is his first truly independent album and maybe is just a bit too self indulgent. It sounds more alternative pop than prog. It is typically regarded as either a love it/hate it album by the faithful.
Steve Wilson stepped in and helped produce & write 1997's
Sunsets on Empire and I think the songs have more than a passing resemblance to how Wilson was developing the sound of Porcupine Tree during the same era. This album has my favorite Fish track "
Sunsets on Empire" which combines Fish's cutting lyrics on a failing relationship set to a Pink Floyd type soundscape complete with a Clare Torry type vocal solo.
I think he hit a rough spot in the early 2000(s) which had
Fellini Days (2001) &
Field of Crows (2004). A couple of good songs on each but in my opinion are awful albums. I came close to writing the big man off with
Field of Crows which had some abysmal lyrics and out of character music.
That leaves 2007's
13th Star which is my second favorite album. Fish seems to return to his earlier roots with emotionally charged interpersonal lyrics and neo-prog music.
You can also consider 1993's cover album called
Songs from the Mirror, where he has some pretty good covers of ? by the Moody Blues, Fearless by Pink Floyd, I Know What I Like by Genesis, Time and a Word (w/ Steve Howe) by Yes, and 5 Years by Bowie.
If you want to hear stuff more like
Weltschmerz:
- Raingods with Zippos
- A Feast of Consequences
If you want to hear stuff with more witty wordplay, attitude, & emotion:
- Vigil in a Wilderness of Mirrors
- 13th Star
- Internal Exile
If you want to hear how Steve Wilson influences an album:
If you made it this far and are still interested:
- Suits - If you like Vigil, Internal, Sunsets better
- Fellini Days - If you like Weltschmerz, Raingods, Feast
- Field of Crows - If you want to torture yourself