I'm sure it is a US release that had found its way to the Audiojumble Event in Tonbridge, Kent, England where I bought it.
Thank you!
I'm sure it is a US release that had found its way to the Audiojumble Event in Tonbridge, Kent, England where I bought it.
So are we now going to criticize the "fake live crowd" on Sgt Peppers by The Beatles? I think that misses the point of the artistic choices that were made on some pretty friggin' brilliant recordings, by some pretty prolific music legends who filled many a stadium of "real" live crowds...Agreed. The fake live crowd doesn't do it any favors, either.
A 10 for the Blu-ray audio multichannel PCM mix. It is better than the sound quality on the SACD, which sounds harsher and has less bass than the blu-ray. Noticeable when cranked up. I would give the SACD an 8.
Well, you see, Benny is hitting the stage and is known as someone who can change the weather. When that piano note halts for a second and then continues - which the arena audience is in ecstasy - it really is a good thrilling vibe. Love that fake audience, or I mean real audience flown in from another live album. I wonder which live album that used?Agreed. The fake live crowd doesn't do it any favors, either.
Well, you see, Benny is hitting the stage and is known as someone who can change the weather. When that piano note halts for a second and then continues - which the arena audience is in ecstasy - it really is a good thrilling vibe. Love that fake audience, or I mean real audience flown in from another live album. I wonder which live album that used?
Well, you see, Benny is hitting the stage and is known as someone who can change the weather. When that piano note halts for a second and then continues - which the arena audience is in ecstasy - it really is a good thrilling vibe. Love that fake audience, or I mean real audience flown in from another live album. I wonder which live album that used?
If you watch the "Classic Albums" DVD on this album (I believe it might have been included in the deluxe SACD set, or at least part of it was), they discuss adding in the whistles and the crowd noise. In fact, as I recall, they are sitting at the console and they pot up the crowd noise as it's heard.
The mix on the Blu-ray is by Greg Penny and is the same as on the SACD and the DVD-A. Bob Ludwig did do the 2014 remaster however. The info is in the booklet included with the Blu-ray.No doubt at all about the 2014 remaster by Bob Ludwig on the blu-ray audio - his 5.1 mix is considerably superior to the 2003 Greg Penny SACD 5.1 mix. I purchased the blu-ray before the SACD and then after reading all about how different they were, I thought I'd get the SACD to test my equipment and hear for myself if there was any noticeable difference. I don't use graphs and waveforms and dynamic range print-outs to hear a difference. It's not only the mix that is better but the sound is much fuller and more dynamic on the blu-ray audio. The SACD never gets played now. And the blu-ray audio is a 10/10.
View attachment 78719
Yes - you are correct. On the booklet is does say "2014 remaster" by Bob Ludwig - he certainly made a lot of changes to the levels!The mix on the Blu-ray is by Greg Penny and is the same as on the SACD and the DVD-A. Bob Ludwig did do the 2014 remaster however. The info is in the booklet included with the Blu-ray.
Wasn’t it just the stereo mix which was remastered by Ludwig for the blu-ray (and every other format in 2014)?Yes - you are correct. On the booklet is does say "2014 remaster" by Bob Ludwig - he certainly made a lot of changes to the levels!
What "levels" are you speaking of? This was not a new remix in 5.1, so various instruments were not changed in levels. Song to song levels can appear different, and tonally there can be differences, but not in the mix.Yes - you are correct. On the booklet is does say "2014 remaster" by Bob Ludwig - he certainly made a lot of changes to the levels!
I'm assuming channel level differences? That can be done in mastering.What "levels" are you speaking of? This was not a new remix in 5.1, so various instruments were not changed in levels. Song to song levels can appear different, and tonally there can be differences, but not in the mix.
The Ludwig credit is for the *stereo remaster* of 2014, included on the BluRayI'm assuming channel level differences? That can be done in mastering.