And no Atmos in a 2023 BD package? Can SWT explain why no Atmos, or did I miss that already?
It’s a very relevant question - there are several reasons.
Yes, I am not currently set up with a system for Atmos, but I am in the process of getting involved.
It seems not all projects are commissioned for Atmos versions, and many of the projects I have mixed were actually completed some time ago. I do appreciate that demand is building.
It isn’t as simple as just choosing an extra output format, it requires more time to reconfigure and rethink. I wouldn’t want to just rely on a downscaling from Atmos to 5.1 and stereo - so far my main focus has been to refine my vision for 5.1 and stereo versions. It also means it will require more budget and more time!
I do expect my approach to extra channels to be somewhat cautious - there seems to be a demand for gimmicky and discrete use of the extra channels, and that has almost never been my goal. For me it's the mix itself rather than the format that is important, and how it suits the material, the emotions and atmospheres. I treat mixing like creating a movie - sometimes you want the screen to be full of detail, but other times the colour, depth of field and the focus is what it is all about. Sometimes black and white works!!
You also have to bear in mind that new mixes for albums like this are derived from 8 and 4 track tapes - and the way those recordings were structured leaves you with only so much control - although new technology does allow for some deconstruction and separation - again it depends on how the particular original production was made. Artists had to be very decisive then, and there was no undo button!
Enough said for now!! SWT