As I reflect on it, I would like to see that scale included in the first post for each poll so it is super easy to find.
Without the expected scale in front of you, it is sometimes hard to remember how to rate releases.
30% SURROUND MIX
30% AUDIO FIDELITY
30% CONTENT
10% OVERALL PACKAGE
Thx for this by the way I did struggle to find rules for the surround Poll
I need to get this Pineapple Thief Blu-ray as it certainly has generated a lot of discussion on this forum.
Still I cannot give it more than 8 because I felt so melancholy that before bed I drank a whiskey and came to the conclusion that the Grateful Dead song Dire Wolf really was a happy song.
I hope I am reprieved and you wont de-member me.
I thank you for this being parted from my member for too long will make my wife happy and reduce my 5.1 to 5.0 ( lack of bass means no Omph in the bedroom )An 8 is respectable.
OK guys, we can put away the guillotine now. We can't have Tezzalavell going around member-less because of an 8.
By the way Mr. Baggins , Sir . I Know not how I Iived before LIFE IN SURROUNDI thank you for this being parted from my member for too long will make my wife happy and reduce my 5.1 to 5.0 ( lack of bass means no Omph in the bedroom )
....
...The Prog I know is symphonic , mellotron based , soaring guitars etc. . This sounded more like Depeche Mode in their Industrial phase !! So I shut my ears, threw my toys out the pram switched off and wrote a very unworthy review. Sooorrryyy !
.......
A New review to supersede the old one. Firstly let me explain the first listen if I can. I bought this blind without sampling . As a Somerset band and I live in Somerset they have somehow escaped me. No excuses. The Prog I know is symphonic , mellotron based , soaring guitars etc. . This sounded more like Depeche Mode in their Industrial phase !! So I shut my ears, threw my toys out the pram switched off and wrote a very unworthy review. Sooorrryyy !
Tonight I listened through my Lucy in the Sky with Diamonds ears ( kidding) to both the album and the bonus.
Its alternative rock , percussion driven , very sparse , no melodic crescendos not what I would call Prog at all . So apart from that what can I say. Its very immersive probably the most immersive album I have listened to. Yet it is discrete especially the bonus album.
But for me who is a person who has little patience, this album has left me undecided as to how many times I will play it. Either an album hooks me straight away or I stare at it in my surround album bookcase and pass it over. I will play it again because as all you guys say the surround mix is a good un
Fidelity, package (value for money) , mix are top notch ( I withdraw my Phil Spector remark until they release All things must pass. Please God don’t do it) .
Still I cannot give it more than 8 because I felt so melancholy that before bed I drank a whiskey and came to the conclusion that the Grateful Dead song Dire Wolf really was a happy song.
I hope I am reprieved and you wont de-member me.
By the way for all concerned my system is reasonably OK and my 13 years B&Ws disguised as Sony can still thump it out . I’m afraid all the damage was me ! My Bad on this one!
You don't HAVE to like something because everyone here likes it.
For me Versions of The Truth is The best song in 2020For me this is the best NEW album in 5.1 for 2020. I got the blur ay only version and what a value. The alternative mixes in 5.1 are out of this world. On " Demons" alternative mix... Gavin Garrison's percussion is coming from everywhere. What a track in 5.1!! Bruce Scoord is a genuis !
I am new to TPT. What is your favorite track off of VOTT? I'm listening to the Blu-Ray of 'Where We Stood" right now. Good album. Great fidelity. Loaded with content. Cheap as f*ck. I'm actually quite fond of the instrumental pieces off of "8 Years Later"--'Hallucinations and Delusions' and 'The Confined Escape.' I know they're mainly a rock oufit, but I would love to hear them explore more of the instrumental side. Really nice vibe, these 2 tracks.I admit that I'm somewhat prejudiced because the style of Versions of the Truth is what I consider right in my wheelhouse...a fusion of a number of styles loaded with hooks and harmonies. Other things I really like about this album:
- Superb fidelity
- Perfect tonal balance
- 5.1 mix
- No run-on songs. It's about 45 minutes for 10 songs...all make their point musically and lyrically and then it's on to the next song.
A 9+, so I gave it a 10.