Thanks! Can’t remember how I Acquired this one but have had it for a while!You have the 30th Anniversary CD/DVD set that features the Brian May mix.
Thanks! Can’t remember how I Acquired this one but have had it for a while!You have the 30th Anniversary CD/DVD set that features the Brian May mix.
I think that version is worth keeping for the “Seaside Rendezvous” video aloneYou have the 30th Anniversary CD/DVD set that features the Brian May mix.
I have no idea what I have!
I listened to it and enjoyed the videos but the mix was average in my opinion. I saw in the liner notes that both May and Schiener were involved in the mix.It is the 2005 (i.e., DTS-only) version, the one with added dynamic range compression on the 5.1 mix and the first true 5.1 mix of God Save the Queen.
Thanks for doing the analysis! We appreciate it!I've kindly been supplied with a track from the BluRay, in LPCM, DTS and DTS-MA. The latter two require decoding, which I have not done yet. But here's the previous image, with the BluRay LPCM added on top
Left channel of 5.1 Bohemian Rhapsody, top to bottom
2021 Bluray - LPCM
2005 DTS (decoded)
2002 DVDA - DTS (decoded)
2002 DVDA - LPCM
Apart from the obvious -- the 2021 BluRay is the same as the 2005 DTS, compression and all (making 'hi rez' rather pointless, incidentally) -- I have highlighted an interesting thing. These waveforms are all micro-aligned (by me) at the right end of the white highlight block. Note that the 2005 and 2002 waveforms are no longer aligned at the left end of the white block. This indicates the 2002 is shorter/runs faster than the 2005. I haven't confirmed with a pitch analysis yet.View attachment 81038
Or it could mean there is an edit(s) somewhere. I’m not saying there is, but at a glance it seems like the misalignment happens fairly suddenly and then maintains after that.I've kindly been supplied with a track from the BluRay, in LPCM, DTS and DTS-MA. The latter two require decoding, which I have not done yet. But here's the previous image, with the BluRay LPCM added on top
Left channel of 5.1 Bohemian Rhapsody, top to bottom
2021 Bluray - LPCM
2005 DTS (decoded)
2002 DVDA - DTS (decoded)
2002 DVDA - LPCM
Apart from the obvious -- the 2021 BluRay is the same as the 2005 DTS, compression and all (making 'hi rez' rather pointless, incidentally) -- I have highlighted an interesting thing. These waveforms are all micro-aligned (by me) at the right end of the white highlight block. Note that the 2005 and 2002 waveforms are no longer aligned at the left end of the white block. This indicates the 2002 is shorter/runs faster than the 2005. I haven't confirmed with a pitch analysis yet.View attachment 81038
Ahh I see now I think (I’m viewing it on my phone so it’s small) - the areas before and after the highlighted area are in of sync. But the highlighted area looks pretty synched up so there is either an edit in both non-highlighted areas or they pasted in two (or more) separate pieces outside the highlighted area which run at different speeds. The former seems more likely to me, but it could be either could be possible I suppose.Such an edit could not be *after* the highlighted area in the above image. If it was, the entire length from nonhighlighted start to the right end of the white box, would have been aligned.
Now, if I instead extremely carefully** align the waveforms at the *start*, instead of in the middle of the track, the 2021/2005 are already obviously out of synch with the 2002 by ~2.8 sec into the alignment:
View attachment 81080
This suggests a speed difference, not an edit, as the cause
**as before, the alignment was done at a much higher magnification than this image, this time at a point ~0.7 sec into the alignment, i.e. where the white highlight box starts.
NB the BluRay was released in 2013, not 2021.I've kindly been supplied with a track from the BluRay, in LPCM, DTS and DTS-MA. The latter two require decoding, which I have not done yet. But here's the previous image, with the BluRay LPCM added on top
Left channel of 5.1 Bohemian Rhapsody, top to bottom
2021 Bluray - LPCM
2005 DTS (decoded)
2002 DVDA - DTS (decoded)
2002 DVDA - LPCM
Apart from the obvious -- the 2021 BluRay is the same as the 2005 DTS, compression and all (making 'hi rez' rather pointless, incidentally) -- I have highlighted an interesting thing. These waveforms are all micro-aligned (by me) at the right end of the white highlight block. Note that the 2005 and 2002 waveforms are no longer aligned at the left end of the white block. This indicates the 2002 is shorter/runs faster than the 2005. I haven't confirmed with a pitch analysis yet.View attachment 81038
Enter your email address to join: