I wiped the disc down with a microfiber cloth and now it's ripping! Looked like it had some sort of residue on it, and I only handle by the edges, so....
All good! Thanks for the suggestions!
All good! Thanks for the suggestions!
Sony Blu-Ray Players used for SACD ripping
- Thread starter beerking
- Start date
Help Support QuadraphonicQuad:
Well I'll be an unkies muckle. I was able to get the Oppo 103 with the Russian firmware to rip last night.
I don't know specifically what differences there are in the different versions of AutoScript. I used the one @beerking listed early in the thread for the Sony, and the newer one for the Oppo. For both I used the latest version of sacdextract.
Anyway both are ripping SACD.
I had a lot of problems ripping with the RussOppo a while back and gave up on it after finally getting a few successful rips and then was fully caught up on my SACD ripping. I figured it was a fluke, considering scripting is supposedly disabled in the firmware. But I need to do more testing with the Oppo, i.e. some more rips. If they go off smoothly then I'll be happy. Other than 4K playback the Oppo is truly very versatile with the Russian firmware, and ripping SACD is the icing on the cake.
But the cheap Sony S590 will remain as a "fallback" ripper. I'll keep it "in the rack" and powered as I do two of the Oppo's to keep the juice flowing.
I have 5 more Vocallion SACD's in transit so a good opportunity for more testing.
Again this thread has been great to refresh on all things SACD ripping and a boon for my "C.R.S" old brain. Thanks to all for the advice and tips.
Anyway both are ripping SACD.
I had a lot of problems ripping with the RussOppo a while back and gave up on it after finally getting a few successful rips and then was fully caught up on my SACD ripping. I figured it was a fluke, considering scripting is supposedly disabled in the firmware. But I need to do more testing with the Oppo, i.e. some more rips. If they go off smoothly then I'll be happy. Other than 4K playback the Oppo is truly very versatile with the Russian firmware, and ripping SACD is the icing on the cake.
But the cheap Sony S590 will remain as a "fallback" ripper. I'll keep it "in the rack" and powered as I do two of the Oppo's to keep the juice flowing.
I have 5 more Vocallion SACD's in transit so a good opportunity for more testing.
Again this thread has been great to refresh on all things SACD ripping and a boon for my "C.R.S" old brain. Thanks to all for the advice and tips.
Yep the Oppo is ripping away. Win win. Just needed the right AutoScript folder/files.
Hi All, it has been a while since I ripped a sacd using sacdextractgui. It has worked all the way up until today. I ping the port and it is accessible, but i continue to get the following "error" mesage during ripping, with no ISO generated.
libsacdread: Can't open 192.168.68.83:2002 for reading
Any help would be appreciated
MacOS 14.4.1 (M1 Macbook air)
Kind regards,
Mark
libsacdread: Can't open 192.168.68.83:2002 for reading
Any help would be appreciated
MacOS 14.4.1 (M1 Macbook air)
Kind regards,
Mark
Simon A
2K Club - QQ Super Nova
- Joined
- Jun 13, 2015
- Messages
- 3,167
I suspect the latest Mac OS upgrade is the culprit.
SACD_ripper
Senior Member
This is the problem.
It is, and no indication as to exactly why or how to fix. A Java fix has already been pushed, however that doesn't seem to resolve this so I'm guessing there is some sort of new Apple top secret permissions thing preventing the use of an unsigned application.
@SACD_ripper do you know of any alternative apps for MacOS that work like sacdextractgui? thanks
SACD_ripper
Senior Member
It's not the GUI itself that is the problem, or at least not by the looks of there already having been a Java fix/update pushed. SACDExtractGUI is just a Java-based front end graphical user interface tool that allows you to point and click as opposed to issue commands on a CLI.
The problem appears to be with running or executing an unsigned application, that being sacd_extract.
I guess there could still be some remaining incompatibility with the Java applet itself, however it was bad news to see that rips also fail with macOS 14.4 when using the CLI, which has nothing to do with Java or use of any GUI.
bigwig91700
New member
Hello, I would like to know if the process for ripping a SACD using a Sony 5100 is it still current?
SACD_ripper
Senior Member
Nothing has changed with regard to S5100 compatibility or the actual steps in the process, however depending on which computer operating system you use there can be differences with the setup, and currently macOS 14.4+ is completely broken.
Wow, good question. I haven't had to rip a SACD in my 5100 in a long time.
If no one here can help I would recommend asking at Hi Fi Haven where much of
the background work was done.
Good luck,
Sal
https://hifihaven.org/index.php?threads/rip-sacd-with-a-blu-ray-player.3652/#post-69000
bigwig91700
New member
Thanks 
bigwig91700
New member
I'am using VM with Windows 11 .
Still working for me.
bigwig91700
New member
Same exact error and issue for me, just encountered for the first time and a real kick in the beans. Running a 2023 Mac Studio on Sonoma 14.4.1. Luckily I didn't pitch my old iMac when I upgraded, but what an annoying thing to have to do to make this work. If/when there's ever a solution, I'm sure we'll all keep one another updated here. Blah.
reidc
Active Member
I just picked up a Sony BDP-BX510 and will attempt to try ripping. I've been using a BDP-S870 for the last 12 yrs to playback SACD-R's. Picked it up on the FleaBay for 25 and it still had its remote. The guy was 20 miles from me as well.
Chris
Chris
Hello
"I've been using a BDP-S870..."
I can't find BDP-S870 on google. Do you have a link?
I have a Sony BDP-S780 .. . playback SACD-R works.Similar threads
