Maybe think of this as a disappointing blessing. One of my favorite bands, Marillion—who I believe are perfect candidates for surround sound—have released some really underwhelming 5.1 mixes, even from usually reliable sources. Honestly, the disappointment of hearing a weak mix feels worse than simply wishing there was one.Was hoping I’d wake up today and see Radiohead the Bends in Atmos for the 30th anniversary………but noooooooo god forbid Radiohead mix some of there catalog into Atmos not that the music isn’t perfect for it.
Rolling Stones Atmos tracks on Apple are definitely upmixed from stereo.Not holding my breath, but...let's hope for some good mixes.
I would have liked them to more aggressively use what ATMOS offers, but I do hear more space around the musical elements, especially the drums. To your point, I wouldn’t spend money to get these new mixes, but dont have to since they come with my Apple Music subscription.The new Stones Atmos mixes are terrible. What's the point of mixing them like this or even doing surround mixes.
You are "wish-remembering" as the only 5.1 mix was "Sympathy For The Devil" on the SACD single.Rolling Stones Atmos tracks on Apple are definitely upmixed from stereo.
I remember having some of the SACD releases back in 2000 something and I can hear the multichannel mix of 2000 light years from home in my head, but maybe I'm wish-membering that.
Sadly not available in the US.Don’t know if this has been posted before
Quite a gap of important albums between Now! in February '65 to Let It Bleed in late '69.either it's a mistake or a slew of The Rolling Stones' albums are coming in Atmos as they're the new Spatial Audio Featured Artist on Apple Music but when you playthrough they're all Stereo only
View attachment 114828
View attachment 114829
I'm listening to it now. I agree, there is separation but more like a standard 5.1 mix, still it's better than what we had before.I don’t think Let It Bleed in Atmos is that bad. It certainly could have been a bit more adventurous, but I’m hearing a few good things and the separation gives Nicky a little more clarity in the mix. Now the early albums are definitely not that great, but there’s not a lot you can do with old 4 track recordings. If they were even 4 track!