I have the 5.1 of this and had no intention of upgrading to the Atmos, though I have an Atmos system. It was super-thoughtless of them to sell the same album twice this way.
Anyway, a very close friend bought me this for my birthday - and in a record store that was selling it for far too high a price. So that was terribly nice of my friend. I shall always think of him when I reach for it from the shelf behind my left shoulder where I keep all my PF-related multichannel stuff. And it's quite nicely packaged too, isn't it? And the menu music? That's at the top of the menu music hit parade. Oh, and I was grateful to see that the fab little pig in the pop-up menu is still there, happily intact.
So, to my score. I'm pretty sure I gave the 5.1 one a ten, and this one is a ten as well. Mind you, my rating would have been a nine, without my wee little pop-up pig friend.
But now my thoughtful, generous friend has left me in such a quandary. Just what do I do with my 5.1 copy? I don't know anybody else in my social circle with a blu-ray player, let alone a surround system.