OK- not seeing the doc I wouldn't have noticed that; thanks for the clarification. It seems to me that Tony and Phil have really devalued the early years of the band- which many of us feel are their best. Perhaps a reaction to many fans feeling that once PG (or SH) left, the band sold out, or wasn;t really Genesis anymore or fiil-in-the-blank w/ whatever derogatory comment.
I think there is so much cry for SW to remix Genesis in surround b/c so many are dissatisfied w/ the results of that 1st attempt. Personally, I love those 5.1 mixes, even if they're not perfect. But I only have through W&W, as my dissatisfaction w/ ATTWT led me to get off the bus then- and from what I've read, the later mixes suffered more. Though plenty of people still seem to dislike all the re-mixes.
We need you to quote some current SW tweets/facebook posts to get us firmly back on topic RT!
Tony and Phil devalue the early stuff? Yes and no. From the new doc, all members seem to still love tracks like "The Musical Box" and "Supper's Ready". "The Lamb" is where the divide begins to happen. Peter and Phil love it musically (even though Phil hated the costumes) while Tony really dislikes it. Mike & Steve are probably in the middle.
Hopefully SW has more news for us soon, either on his pages or here directly!