I haven't tried Atmos over headphones but I have tried 360 Reality Audio and other binaural audio and to be honest it just sounds like wide stereo to me. I know they say there are specific headphones designed for it but it doesn't really resemble anything like surround to me. I think it could be more of a marketing ploy designed to appeal to a broader market perhaps? If it broadens the surround market then it's all good to me!
Yeah I agree. I think there might've been an assumption on some songs that a Dolby Atmos renderer might have produced the mix, but I think even in this case the mixer has just gone for a 'true to the stereo' mix instead. For the majority of stuff it's usually discrete.
This song when played in surround actually has a mixing error to me. The same with '
Rufus - Tell Me Something Good'. I think the main vocal got sent to the rear channels by mistake.
Hoping that it might get fixed one day...
All in all I really like listening to Atmos. It completely opens up the surround field when done well. The Kraftwerk and Booka Shade are reference quality but some of the Tidal pop and soul mixes are really good too.
These are also some of the best in my opinion...