HiRez Poll Yes - FRAGILE [Blu-Ray Audio (Dolby Atmos)]

[Jim.olga]

Just my opinion
The top of the page states the poll is for the blu ray audio atmos mix
No mention of the boxset!

If this poll is only for the BDA and not the whole set then my initial understanding of what should be rated was correct as a 10. If there is a consensus that this poll is only from the BDA and not the whole set, I will again adjust my vote back to a 10. Not being coerced or wishy washy because I believe the BDA is a 10 and the LP quality brings the rating down to a 9.

As a true believer in the democratic process if there is a consensus among the group that this poll is just for the BDA and not the entire set then a 10 rating for me is justified. With that, all in favor of this poll being only for the BDA give my comment here a thumbs up. All opposed give an angry face. Let's settle this controversy once and for all.

 

[Marplot]

The overall package is 10% of the rating. Dropping that point due to the forced inclusion of vinyl and the quality of it is reasonable.
While I am unhappy with the inclusion, I will only drop half a point which on a 10 point scale will round back up to a 10.
In ATMOS it is the best I have ever heard the album.