Not so fast, my friend.
Let the record show that the first like for this post came from the guy who, when setting up his new box that is the topic of this thread & got confused, did not post in this thread.
Instead, he posted in the Listening to in Dolby Atmos Streaming, via Tidal/Apple thread, where some folks tried to help him out while I gave him a hard time.
Some people are just confused and looking for answers.
Your example is Apple computer owners questioning if it's mandatory to buy one of these boxes just to try listening to Apple Music in surround to see what the excitement is all about.
Folks who already bought Apple TV then assert that's the only way.
Correct as far as full-blown Atmos goes.
However one can in fact "play the Atmos tracks" downmixed to 5.1 without it, so I replied and directed him to another thread with details.
Then a week later comes another well-intentioned post:
Missed it, then. It happens.
OK.
Not in my experience.
Hence a reply from me, and a couple of confirming follow-ups.
Sorry if you feel that's degraded the integrity of a thread with 120 posts, not all of which are laser-focused on point.
This place is never going to be perfect.
Maybe we can cut each other some slack.
Except for @GOS . I'm at the end of my rope with that guy.
One man's opinion, agree or disagree.
I wasn't trying to be that guy, but so many ATV discussions popped up in other places that it made sense to build an area for troubleshooting and setup.
For the record, I'm a huge Mac fan, but the Mac convo is so far from AppleTV, just like one might say 5.1 downmixed Atmos isn't really Atmos? LOL. I mean, I know 5.1 downmixed to stereo isn't really 5.1.... just sayin'
But my point is the tips, the features, the issues are all different between the two platforms. For many people, AppleTV is their first Apple device. It's easy to get lost between Mac and ATV issues.
I seriously want us to have both! And I'd love to convince more people to call support / submit feedback on issues so we can get some of the lingering issues addressed.