HiRez Poll King Crimson - ISLANDS [DVD-A/BDA]

[Matt Wilson]

Listening to the blu on the Sailors' Tales box.
A 9 easily. Not the best Crimso '70s LP (their worst, actually), but the sound is incredible.

 

[sjcorne]

Does anyone else hear a high-pitched noise in the track Islands? It starts somewhere around 6 minutes into the song. It sounds like my ear is ringing, but it's coming from the left speaker (on stereo). I've tested both CD and DVD-A and they both have it. Anyone else have this issue?

Only a decade later, but I just got this disc and am having the exact same issue. Is this what it's like to have tinnitus? Spectrogram view in Audacity does show a tone at around 17 or 18k starting near the six-minute mark.

 

[AYanguas]

Only a decade later, but I just got this disc and am having the exact same issue. Is this what it's like to have tinnitus? Spectrogram view in Audacity does show a tone at around 17 or 18k starting near the six-minute mark.

I see this also with Audacity. Just when the trumpet start at aprox 06:00 in the two surround channels. But I cannot hear anything abnormal in my system, apart from a very slightly bothered trumpet by the high pitch. My ear cannot hear anything at such 17kHz high frequency.

 

[H.A.L.]

Living in the South, we are (of course) subject to many rainstorms, and I love blasting this 5.1 loudly when one is in progress .

KC takes me back to my early youth. In that way, they will always live in my heart. And all the recent box releases are way beyond my teenage dreams / fantasies! So much so, I haven't explored it all yet. But I will eventually, and be grateful for the latter-day chance.

 

[anibal]

Listening to the DVD-A for the second time today.
This one is amazing, better than I remembered. This album deserves more attention, or at least I don't know many fans of it. And the 5.1 mix is perfect for me! The lyrics of Ladies of the Road haven't aged well, but it is so catchy, and that gorgeous vocal arrangement for the chorus...
An easy 10.

BTW, the first time I heard this record was in an awfull 4th generation argentian vinyl pressing, with the noise floor closer to the main vocals level! The 30th anniversary version was already a blessing to me, and then the surround mix elevates the experience to preposterous levels of blisfullness.

 

[ieltxumetal]

Listening to the DVD-A for the second time today.
This one is amazing, better than I remembered. This album deserves more attention, or at least I don't know many fans of it. And the 5.1 mix is perfect for me! The lyrics of Ladies of the Road haven't aged well, but it is so catchy, and that gorgeous vocal arrangement for the chorus...
An easy 10.

BTW, the first time I heard this record was in an awfull 4th generation argentian vinyl pressing, with the noise floor closer to the main vocals level! The 30th anniversary version was already a blessing to me, and then the surround mix elevates the experience to preposterous levels of blisfullness.

Same just happened to me.

The 5.1 mix really improves the listening experience.

Super job Steven Wilson on this one. Solid 10.

 

[Degrundt]

Islands has never been my favorite KC album. In fact, i've always thought it's hard to believe it's a KC album (only Sailor's tale really sounds "Crimsonian" by exaggerating a foot). But the melancolic "ambiance" has always been fascinating for me.
This 5.1 remix is a revelation. My EG CD was a very bad entry to this piece. I put a 10 without any reserve on the technical work.

 

[jimfisheye]

How did I miss this poll?!

This 5.1 remix puts on a finishing touch that this album never had and opens up the fidelity in a shocking way!

My 1st copy was the late '80s EG half speed mastered vinyl. So a really classy introduction to begin with and I avoided some really bad copies apparently. This remix reinvents it in all the right ways.

Both this and Lizard are the "in between" albums for sure. These might be some of the best Wilson remixes though as he has brought them up near the standard of the rest of the albums in a way.

 

[Degrundt]

How did I miss this poll?!

This 5.1 remix puts on a finishing touch that this album never had and opens up the fidelity in a shocking way!

My 1st copy was the late '80s EG half speed mastered vinyl. So a really classy introduction to begin with and I avoided some really bad copies apparently. This remix reinvents it in all the right ways.

Both this and Lizard are the "in between" albums for sure. These might be some of the best Wilson remixes though as he has brought them up near the standard of the rest of the albums in a way.

"In between" is a very judicious wording.

 

[himey]

"In between" is a very judicious wording.

Lizard is excellent.

 

[jimfisheye]

Lizard is excellent.

I never picked up on all the hocketing going on throughout this album originally. Liked it well enough even if I might have called it "in between". Wilson essentially finished this mix and just nailed all those arrangement balances! Both of these albums are a light year beyond expectations!

 

[Degrundt]

I never picked up on all the hocketing going on throughout this album originally. Liked it well enough even if I might have called it "in between". Wilson essentially finished this mix and just nailed all those arrangement balances! Both of these albums are a light year beyond expectations!

There is no bad King Crimson albums, there is only albums not as good as others...

 

[jimfisheye]

There is no bad King Crimson albums, there is only albums not as good as others...

The worst would still be near the very top of my favorites list!
So... that's Earthbound, right? Best version of 21st Century Schizoid Man ever!

 

[Degrundt]

The worst would still be near the very top of my favorites list!
So... that's Earthbound, right? Best version of 21st Century Schizoid Man ever!

In fact, due to poor sound quality reported in all the reviews i could have read, i've never listen or buy this one. Should i change my point of view ?

 

[dquad]

In fact, due to poor sound quality reported in all the reviews i could have read, i've never listen or buy this one. Should i change my point of view ?

Earthbound? Unfortunately, the sound quality is poor. This is a deal breaker for me.

 

[jimfisheye]

Poor? Nah... much worse than that. But best version of 21CSM. A few other cool moments if you're in the right mood (for lo-fi). Some of the comments about the drum solo I read cracked me up... and are quite accurate. Earthbound is included in the box if you have the Islands bluray set.

 

[Degrundt]

Poor? Nah... much worse than that. But best version of 21CSM. A few other cool moments if you're in the right mood (for lo-fi). Some of the comments about the drum solo I read cracked me up... and are quite accurate. Earthbound is included in the box if you have the Islands bluray set.

I've only got the CD+DVD combo. The Sailor's Tales boxset is so expensive now.

 

[jimfisheye]

This box was 4 albums in one. Poseidon with the real 5.1 mix of Mars (The original DVD had a poor upmix as a placeholder), Lizard, Islands, and Earthbound. Lots of extras. A little light on surround content beyond the album remixes and a live radio broadcast show mixed in quad but a lot of bang for the buck with 4 albums+.

 

[Degrundt]

This box was 4 albums in one. Poseidon with the real 5.1 mix of Mars (The original DVD had a poor upmix as a placeholder), Lizard, Islands, and Earthbound. Lots of extras. A little light on surround content beyond the album remixes and a live radio broadcast show mixed in quad but a lot of bang for the buck with 4 albums+.

Don't push me !