Listening to in Dolby Atmos Streaming, via Tidal/Apple/Amazon

QuadraphonicQuad

Help Support QuadraphonicQuad:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
I just compared it to the 400M views Video clip on YT and the intro is the same length. About 20 seconds.
I was referring to the vocal that is not cleanly split between this song and the prior song on the album. Prior song has “no digg” and the end and this song starts with “ity” (if that makes sense).

Odd since the entire album wasn’t mixed in Atmos. I would have expected the use of the “single” version that has the full “no diggity” vocal at the start.
 
Last edited:
O - R
A rash of AINO (Atmos-In-Name-Only) mixes in this batch, which is to say: immersive in the broadest, sometimes only the technical, sense of the word, yet not really taking full advantage of what the format offers. A couple of them, like Pat Metheny’s light-but-pleasant Moondial and Ryuichi Sakamoto’s poignant Opus, are built around solo acoustic instruments, so…waddyagonnado? But more often what I’m seeing—hearing—is variations on a template consisting of a 5.1 bed with vocals across the fronts and front-to-back separation ranging anywhere from minimal to highly discrete, then next-to-nothing (silence, reverb, faint or not-so-faint doubling or selective doubling) in the heights, sometimes only the front heights. And that includes mixes in both my “reject” and “keep” piles.

First, the AINO keepers:

Peso Pluma, Éxodo: double album whose first disc is “folkloric” (neo-corrido) and second, “urban” (primarily rap and reggaeton). On Disc 1, especially, the mixer employs a weird effect where one instrument (trombone, guitar) rotates or bounces diagonally around the room while the rest of the (discrete 5.1) mix stays put.

Phosphorescent, Revelator: stirring, symphonic indie-Americana, with shades (for me) of Lambchop and Nashville-era Dylan.

Porridge Radio, Clouds in the Sky They Will Always Be There for Me: fabulous tunes that press all my indie-rock buttons; sorry to hear they’re breaking up (when I only just learned about 'em!).

Ron Miles, Old Main Chapel: a lovely last testament to a sweet man and an unsung jazz giant. It’s a live recording (with Miles’s fellow Coloradans Bill Frisell and Rudy Royston), and it’s on Blue Note. Just so you don’t expect much, surround-wise.

And then the Atmos/AINO discards. I’m a fan of both Pat Metheny and the late-great Ryuichi Sakamoto, but Moondial and Opus are both inessential releases, IMO. I would also toss: Omar Courtz’s Primera Musa (who will rid me of this plague of autotuned chanting over skittery beats?), Opeth’s The Last Will and Testament (prog-metal is just not my jam), Orla Gartland’s Everybody Needs a Hero (intelligent, sometimes spiky, indiepop that’s a little too determined to be clever), Pet Shop Boys’ Nonetheless (not a fan, so no comment), Rachel Chinouriri’s What a Devastating Turn of Events (smarter than your average indie singer-songwriter, but not enough to truly stand out from the crowd), Rae Khalil’s Crybaby (pleasant, proficient, but ultimately run-of-the-mill neo-soul laden with self-help messages), Remi Wolf’s Big Ideas (bubblebum-adjacent, but far from mindless, pop, and yet…see Rachel Chinouriri, above), Residente, Las Letres Ya No Importan (generically wide-ranging “Latino urbano,” but still not quite my thing).

On the stereo tip, I liked Ruth Goller’s Skyllumina (eerie soundscapes and “demented nursery rhymes”—the Guardian's words—from the virtuosic nu-jazz bassist). And I really liked:
  • Previous Industries, Service Merchandise (supertalented Black-nerd trio led by Open Eagle Mike, with chill beats and esoteric samples worthy of Prince Paul; see this sympathetic review at Pitchfork)
  • Rafael Toral, Spectral Evolution (47-minute drone/ambient outing with high-register low-brass jazz and electronic birdsong & coyote howls)
  • Rosie Tucker, Utopia Now! (blunt, blasé, and smart-ass—another spiritual granddaughter of Liz Phair)
  • Rufous Nightjar, Songs for Three Voices (stunning modern-day retro-folk ballads in 3-part harmony; the Dolby Surround Upmixer does amazing things with it)

S - T:
Right off the bat, I’ll admit that I can sort of see the sassy-sweet appeal of Sabrina Carpenter (Short n’ Sweet), and I can’t not respect the savvy success of a girlboss like Taylor Swift (Tortured Poets Society). But I just can’t get excited about their music. Not the target demographic, I guess—though have I also mentioned what a churlish anti-poptimist I can be? Luckily, Ariana Grande, Chappel Roan, Charli XCX, and Dua Lipa also don’t need my approval.

At least a few of the other S - T Atmos albums that leave me loath (DJ/singer Shygirl’s Club Shy EP), indifferent (Nigerian R&B rising-star Tems’s Born In the Wild, contemporary-classical composer Timo Andres’s The Blind Banister), or on the fence (catchy country crooner Shaboozey’s Where I’ve Been, Isn’t Where I’m Going--don't miss "A Bar Song") have decent, or even excellent, mixes going for them. But two more albums that I’d toss in the “equivocal” column (pop-country singer-songwriter Sarah Jarosz’s Polaroid Lovers, South African amapiano beatster Tyla’s TYLA+) are AINO variants, while another (shape-shifting West Coast rapper ScHoolboy Q’s Blue Lips) gets its enveloping feel through four-corner lead vocals and slightly altered copy-and-paste stereo pairs.

The Atmos albums in this slice that I'd spotlight, either for their music or their mix or both:

Samara Joy, Portrait: both her image and her repertoire skew a little conservative for me, but she’s an outrageously talented young singer, and the mix is exceptionally immersive by jazz standards.
Sierra Farrell, Trail of Flowers: absolutely delightful, consummately professional, unabashedly old-school country with a Dolly Parton vibe. Only slightly marred by having one of those pre-set 5.1-in-an-Atmos-wrapper mixes.
Splinter Reeds, Dark Currents: cool minimal-ish music for contemporary wind ensemble (though the second piece adds organ). Fabulous Atmos mix by Cory Todd, although it’s only in the second of the album's two long pieces that the overheads really come into play.
St. Vincent, All Born Screaming: good album with a disappointing mix, especially compared to Mert Ozcan’s more daring approach on her previous outing, Daddy’s Home.
T-Bone Burnett, The Other Side: touching album from a legendary producer. (You forget what a good singer and guitarist he is.) Subtle but surprisingly effective Atmos mix for such a spare production.
And finally, my usual shortlist of stereo standouts:
  • SML, Small Medium Large: improvised ambient afro-electro math-jazz by young LA Turks, including bass whiz Anna Butterss and Meshell Ndegeocello's righthand man Josh Johnson. (Think Can, or late-period Lounge Lizards.) Upmixes nicely.
  • Tyshawn Sorey Trio, The Susceptible Now: sublime set by one of today’s best (MacArthur Genius-led) working piano trios.
 
Last edited:
Here's a new Atmos tune I released yesterday from my synthwave group, let me know what you guys think:

<iframe allow="autoplay *; encrypted-media *;" frameborder="0" height="150" style="width:100%;max-width:660px;overflow:hidden;background:transparent;" sandbox="allow-forms allow-popups allow-same-origin allow-scripts allow-storage-access-by-user-activation allow-top-navigation-by-user-activation" src="
"></iframe>

Also added to my Dolby Atmos favorites playlist on Tidal if you prefer Tidal:

<iframe src="https://embed.tidal.com/playlists/3ec7b538-786d-42ef-887f-96db1c996e37" width="700" height="600" allow="encrypted-media" sandbox="allow-same-origin allow-scripts allow-forms allow-popups" title="TIDAL Embed Player" />

Cheers!
 
I'm definitely hearing some discrete elements here and there (Silvergun Superman), sides mainly - is AI conquering new grounds (spaces) maybe? Anyway, here's my roughly patched playlist for those who want direct comparison to Tiny Music... tracks (clear winners).
Oh, and there are no mixing credits stated on Tidal.
According to the official STP Facebook account, the Core and Purple Atmos mixes are by Ryan Williams. He had worked with the band previously and several other notable artists. I am not sure how many Atmos mixes he has done.
 
S - T:
Right off the bat, I’ll admit that I can sort of see the sassy-sweet appeal of Sabrina Carpenter (Short n’ Sweet), and I can’t not respect the savvy success of a girlboss like Taylor Swift (Tortured Poets Society). But I just can’t get excited about their music. Not the target demographic, I guess—though have I also mentioned what a churlish anti-poptimist I can be? Luckily, Ariana Grande, Chappel Roan, Charli XCX, and Dua Lipa also don’t need my approval.

At least a few of the other S - T Atmos albums that leave me loath (DJ/singer Shygirl’s Club Shy EP), indifferent (Nigerian R&B rising-star Tems’s Born In the Wild, contemporary-classical composer Timo Andres’s The Blind Banister), or on the fence (catchy country crooner Shaboozey’s Where I’ve Been, Isn’t Where I’m Going--don't miss "A Bar Song") have decent, or even excellent, mixes going for them. But two more albums that I’d toss in the “equivocal” column (pop-country singer-songwriter Sarah Jarosz’s Polaroid Lovers, South African amapiano beatster Tyla’s TYLA+) are AINO variants, while another (shape-shifting West Coast rapper ScHoolboy Q’s Blue Lips) gets its enveloping feel through four-corner lead vocals and slightly altered copy-and-paste stereo pairs.

The Atmos albums in this slice that I'd spotlight, either for their music or their mix or both:

Samara Joy, Portrait: both her image and her repertoire skew a little conservative for me, but she’s an outrageously talented young singer, and the mix is exceptionally immersive by jazz standards.

Sierra Farrell, Trail of Flowers: absolutely delightful, consummately professional, unabashedly old-school country with a Dolly Parton vibe. Only slightly marred by having one of those pre-set 5.1-in-an-Atmos-wrapper mixes.

Splinter Reeds, Dark Currents: cool minimal-ish music for contemporary wind ensemble (though the second piece adds organ). Fabulous Atmos mix by Cory Todd, although it’s only in the second of the album's two long pieces that the overheads really come into play.

St. Vincent, All Born Screaming: good album with a disappointing mix, especially compared to Mert Ozcan’s more daring approach on her previous outing, Daddy’s Home.

T-Bone Burnett, The Other Side: touching album from a legendary producer. (You forget what a good singer and guitarist he is.) Subtle but surprisingly effective Atmos mix for such a spare production.

And finally, my usual shortlist of stereo standouts:
  • SML, Small Medium Large: improvised ambient afro-electro math-jazz by young LA Turks, including bass whiz Anna Butterss and Meshell Ndegeocello's righthand man Josh Johnson. (Think Can, or late-period Lounge Lizards.) Upmixes nicely.
  • Tyshawn Sorey Trio, The Susceptible Now: sublime set by one of today’s best (MacArthur Genius-led) working piano trios.

U - Z:
Okay, it’s my last installment—you won’t have to listen to me natter on about 2024 critics’ picks anymore, at least.

I’ll start with a bunch of Atmos “passes” that others might be more inclined to linger on. For instance: Vince Staples is a thoughtful guy and a not-run-of-the-mill rapper, yet his Dark Times, which has a fairly active mix, left me unmoved. Wayne Shorter was a master (RIP) and I know I should welcome any message of his from beyond the grave, but Celebration Vol. 1 didn't quite get through to me. (Also: it was recorded live and released on Blue Note, so...fill in the blanks.) Wishy’s Triple Seven is head-bobbing, dreampoppy indie rock whose Atmos mix is as serviceable as its music is inoffensive. And while Zeal & Ardor’s Greif likewise has a very decent mix, prog metal is just not my thing.

Vampire Weekend, Only God Was Above Us: I never really followed these indie darlings, but I like this new album well enough—though maybe not well enough to put it into heavy (or even light) rotation. Still worth hearing for the wild, playful Dave Fridmann mix alone.
Willie Nelson, Last Leaf on the Tree: how can you not love Willie? Not quite the equivalent of Johnny Cash’s American Recordings, but this is still a great bunch of (mainly) covers, with a conservative—mostly 5.1—mix.
Willow, empathogen/Ceremonial Contrafact (empathogen deluxe): talented overachieving jazz/soul nepo-baby produces a musically ambitious album with another one of those confounding four-corner-vox + pasted-stereo-pairs mixes. (The bonus tracks on the deluxe version are non-Atmos.)
Yard Act, Where’s My Utopia?: slightly arch, slightly goofly, slighty self-lacerating post-indie outing, with maximalist production that’ll remind you of Gorillaz for a reason. (Plus: a cameo by David Thewlis.) Another AINO mix—again, mostly 5.1, but pretty good 5.1.
Zach Top, Cold Beer & Country Music: I never cared for country in the 90s, but I very much like this up-and-comer’s 90s retro vibe. Well-crafted songs, a slick band with some crack players, and an Atmos mix that isn’t afraid to put a fiddle on the ceiling!
And one last selection of outstanding stereo:
  • Various Artists, Nippon Acid Folk 1970-1980: now I know where Cornelius came from. Full album available on Bandcamp; someone constructed an unofficial playlist for AM.
  • Vijay Iyer Trio, Compassion: turns out Tyshawn Sorey (see S – T) keeps the beat for more than one of today’s great jazz piano trios. This one is a quietstorm.
  • Zach Bryan, The Great American Bar Scene: what is it with the profusion of young Zachs on the contemporary country scene? This one is a sensitive/introspective troubadour, and that’s not a put-on.
  • Zacchae’us Paul, Jazz Money: jazz-flavored soul (or maybe vice versa) from a young musical polymath with a heap of Stevie influence. Also: like Nippon Acid Folk, it upmixes nicely with the DSU.
Thanks for reading, thanks for listening. I hope that, like me, you discovered some good new music!
 
Last edited:
Don't get too excited. It's the quad mix, but with the rear channel information duplicated across the side and rear speakers.
For me though, who only had the quad mix from an SQ vinyl conversion, this sounds really good on my 5.1 system. Should have been done as "Dolby Audio" instead though, as Apple has done in the past for a number of old quad and 5.1 mixes, but they seem to have run away from that now.
 
Don't get too excited. It's the quad mix, but with the rear channel information duplicated across the side and rear speakers.
Don’t let this discourage you though. The quad mix is excellent and these guys were one of the best ever! Check out the documentary on Hulu too. One other note: Prince owes much of his career and reputation as a genius to Mr Stewart.
 
Here in the Netherlands the album is also listed under "Featured Albums" in the Spatial Audio section. But indeed, no actual Atmos yet.
Tomorrow hopefully?

Interesting Paul over at SDE didn't get it for a physical release.
If I'm not misremembering, The Hurting was not a streaming exclusive with the SDE disc coming out close.
 
Tomorrow hopefully?

Interesting Paul over at SDE didn't get it for a physical release.
If I'm not misremembering, The Hurting was not a streaming exclusive with the SDE disc coming out close.
Well, maybe an SDE release will surface eventually? After the succesful collaborations in the past, I cannot imagine them passing him by.
Perhaps they now plan on doing a more widely distributed big box. It would be a bit 'low profile' perhaps to just do an SDE blu-ray. So they could do what The Who did: a big comprehensive box first and then a stand-alone blu-ray through SDE. We'll have to wait and see.
 
Well, maybe an SDE release will surface eventually? After the succesful collaborations in the past, I cannot imagine them passing him by.
Perhaps they now plan on doing a more widely distributed big box. It would be a bit 'low profile' perhaps to just do an SDE blu-ray. So they could do what The Who did: a big comprehensive box first and then a stand-alone blu-ray through SDE. We'll have to wait and see.
TFF ‘Songs From The Big Chair’ is showing as available in Dolby Atmos in AU this morning on Apple Music. Should show up elsewhere later in the day.

 

Attachments

  • 1740084682957.png
    1740084682957.png
    1.9 MB
Last edited:
TFF ‘Songs From The Big Chair’ is showing as available in Dolby Atmos in AU this morning on Apple Music. Should show up elsewhere later in the day.
Nice! Hoping Tidal follows suit at midnight.

Curious to see if Broken is still an upmix or if they found the multitracks.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top