Listening now to the DVD of the 2018 5.1 mix, Animals.
Now have listened to the SACD, Blu Ray and DVD.
Of course it would take someone some VERY CRITICAL listening with pen and paper to actually come up with a conclusion as to which one would be the preferred.
I'm just not into it that much.
I need to rip the DVD then I can run all three back and forth and see what some key elements if any differ.
The on screen graphics of the DVD and Blu Ray are different and the DVD 5.1 comes in two versions Dolby Digital 640kbps and Dolby Digital 448kbps.
The long 5+minutes music of the start up menu is the same as the Blu Ray.
If someone was to ask me which one should they buy, I think I would say buy the LP/BD/DVD package.
1. You get two surround discs BD and DVD, (LP and CD).
2. The best of three versions, with best package, artwork, etc.
I am guessing, just based on my memory, the SACD and the DVD are pretty close, a more laid back analog sound.
The Blu Ray a touch brighter.