Interested in comparison between the old and new 5.1 and thoughts on the bonus material. And the doc too. 
Porcupine Tree's "Fear Of A Blank Planet" is Coming - Again, Deluxe Box Set w Blu Ray
- Thread starter Steve Bruzonsky
- Start date
Help Support QuadraphonicQuad:
Does anyone have the Amz link or ASIN number? Thanks!
Thanks a million, ordered from Amz DE
- Joined
- Oct 31, 2012
- Messages
- 141
No standalone release for the 2024 5.1 mix? Just the Deluxe box?
I don't think any of these reissues have been given standalone releases. It's not a new mix for the 5.1 so it's really just a bonus anyways in the set (similar to In Absentia and Deadwing).
- Joined
- Oct 31, 2012
- Messages
- 141
Everybody here was talking about a new 5.1 2024 mix. Was I mistaken in understanding what they were talking about?
It's not a new mix but a new master. The 2007 mix, remastered.
I believe that's right. The menu only says 2024 mix and 2007 mix, IIRC. That would seem to imply two different mixes but....
It should say 2007 master and 2024 remaster not mix.
JediJoker
Audio Engineer/Enthusiast
Given that Steven said that the original multitracks were unusable (old DAW format), there is essentially zero chance of him having completed a new/tweaked mix.
Last edited:
I was looking at the menu when I wrote it, all I can say. Not arguing the point.
I haven't even ordered this yet but I'm already hoping he eventually remasters the 5.1 mix of his first solo album Insurgentes. It's a bit brickwalled and he already remastered the stereo tracks for digital, CD & vinyl re-releases some time ago (DR went from 6 to 9, so it was a noticeable improvement). Plus it's my favorite 5.1 mix of his own music.
Neil Palfreyman
1K Club - QQ Shooting Star
...that's my "fault"
I was asked to play test the 2024 5.1 master on a test BluRay before it went off for pressing, and fed back that although the dynamic range was (obviously) much better than the 2007 master, it had in my opinion lost some "positional balance" and immersiveness as a result of removing the compression.
Steven checked his master again and agreed with me, so he ran out a second remaster which is the one you now hear as the 2024 version, but he also decided at that point to include the 2007 master on the BD, which I thought was a great idea.
(...and yes, it's only been remastered, not remixed but it sounds loads better.
)
Damn you Neil for giving us more choices!
Oh wait, that is a good thing.
Well done, thanks
Oh wait, that is a good thing.
Well done, thanks
...that's my "fault"
I was asked to play test the 2024 5.1 master on a test BluRay before it went off for pressing, and fed back that although the dynamic range was (obviously) much better than the 2007 master, it had in my opinion lost some "positional balance" and immersiveness as a result of removing the compression.
Steven checked his master again and agreed with me, so he ran out a second remaster which is the one you now hear as the 2024 version, but he also decided at that point to include the 2007 master on the BD, which I thought was a great idea.
(...and yes, it's only been remastered, not remixed but it sounds loads better.
Neil, may you continue to be at "fault" testing blu rays! Indeed, apparently, The Doobie Brothers consulted a fortune teller years ago in the 70s and learned about you so many years later, thus their 1977 album "Livin' On The Fault Line".
poll thread has been updated to reflect this recent 5 CD/Blu-Ray reissue:
https://www.quadraphonicquad.com/fo...e-tree-fear-of-a-blank-planet-dvd-a-bda.8699/
https://www.quadraphonicquad.com/fo...e-tree-fear-of-a-blank-planet-dvd-a-bda.8699/
M-K
300 Club - QQ All-Star
Dynamic range increased from DR11 to DR13, Especially the front channels were more compressed in the 2007 master.
Center is a bit reduced and bass (LFE) is on much a lower level. This is what I miss in the 2024 master. But it could easily modified if wanted.
Center is a bit reduced and bass (LFE) is on much a lower level. This is what I miss in the 2024 master. But it could easily modified if wanted.
M-K
300 Club - QQ All-Star
Ah, I forgot to mention that the book is very beautiful and the story very interesting. Although there are some hard facts about "Way out of here"...
The main reason to buy it (again) was the book. As I did before with Deadwing and In Absentia.
The main reason to buy it (again) was the book. As I did before with Deadwing and In Absentia.
Last edited:
JediJoker
Audio Engineer/Enthusiast
Similar threads
- Poll
- Poll
