I finally bought this album last week and I've been spinning it a lot in the past few days, starting with the original mix, then the stereo remix, then the 5.1 mix. Wow, the stereo remix was already a revelation. Brings out so many details that were kinda hidden on the original mix (which, by the way, isn't bad at all in my view, but sounds a bit dated). The 5.1 builds on that and expands the soundstage and instrument clarity in a very tasteful way. It's not wild but, as I said in my review of the
Turn of the Cards set, I think that's the way to showcase Renaissance in surround sound. Nicely discrete but nothing too crazy - it's pretty much like it had sounded in my head before listening to it. It sounds so lush and pristine now that it makes me smile every time I listen to it in this format. It makes the album sound less dated as well, and it's easier to realize that there are still some stunning songs here despite the stylistic change.
Another plus is the video content. It's been wonderfully restored and looks amazing on my 4K OLED TV. Love the acoustic rendition of
Forever Changing.
My only gripe is that both the stereo and surround remixes seem to have been mastered a bit too loud for my tastes, and clearly louder that the original mix remaster. They're definitely not brickwalled, so it's not terrible by any means, but could have been better. Anyway, it hardly detracts from my enjoyment as it still sounds really good. Oh, and the tracklist for the video content is printed differently on the box and on the booklet, and BOTH are wrong
Again, I always find these clamshell style boxes a bit cheap in looks and feel but on the other hand the content is terrific, the extras (bonus tracks, video content and really nice liner notes) are absolutely worth getting and what Stephen W Tayler did here is a gift for any Renaissance fan. This gets a strong 9 from me.
If only the full multitracks from the other Renaissance albums had been available