Hello Quaddies. I found this thread looking for "handshake" and I'm wondering if you have some advice for me... I'm currently looking into getting a new receiver (nowhere near the OP's budget though - I have around 500 dollars). Quick back story, I bought a Yamaha RX-V661 (from 2008) to replace my Samsung HW-C560 HTIB (from 2010, but I thought it would be technically inferior). Despite its excellent rep, the Yamaha underperforms in pretty much everything I want to do.
The Yamaha is great for Oppo BDP-83 over HDMI (SACD, DVD-A, Blu Rayany other source), but I rarely use that. I usually play back all my sound from PC over analogue 5.1 (Sound Blaster X-Fi Surround 5.1 Pro). Sources vary from MP3 to hi-res FLAC. And for that, the Yamaha fails tremendously. It sounds like a transistor radio.
I have spent the past 4 days troubleshooting every piece of equipment I have and I have now decided to sell the Yamaha again. The next time, I want to be sure I get a receiver that does well what I want.
That said, I have found out that in addition to the Sound Blaster's 6-channel analogue out, I can also use my NVIDIA card's HDMI for anything from stereo to 7.1. That works with my Samsung, but leaves the Yamaha silent (haven't figured out why. My best guess is it passes the audio through to my VGA screen instead of just playing it back. It has no option to change that behaviour). Over the Samsung, I am getting pretty bad handshake issues:
When I play back any source from the PC over HDMI with the Samsung receiver, the first 2-3 seconds are cut off before I hear audio. That's, I guess, the time it takes for the HDMI handshake. The issue is compounded by the fact that whenever there is silence, the next note after it is cut off as well. When I change the source (load any other file or playback program), I lose another 2-3 seconds. When there is silence in the same source, the first milliseconds of the next note are cut off. An example is this song at 2:45:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y48PTClxPVw
The music after the breaks are quickly faded in over HDMI and optical, while over analogue, everything sounds as it should.
This only happens from my PC, not from the Oppo. So that leads me to believe the Samsung loses the sound signal from PC as soon as there is any silence.
Before I buy another receiver, can you let me know your experiences with handshaking? Is this simply something one has to contend with in the digital age, or do modern receivers no longer have this issue? If so, which brand do you recommend? Really, all I want is to listen to stereo or surround sources from my PC in good quality. I'm not a gourmet, just a guy who appreciates nice sounding music from any source.
Let me know if you need any more info, and I hope you can help me. Thanks!