I think of these as “candy bar books”... a quick hit to take the edge off, but you shouldn’t always expect a lot of lasting nourishment.
I enjoy reading in bed at night. Sometimes my capacity at the end of the day doesn’t allow for something deep, so books like this where you can read a chapter (one album) in about 10 minutes hits the spot. I’ve read a handful of these and this is the latest.
If you keep in mind that it’s just one author’s opinion (this guitar solo is good, this one isn’t), and that there’s not always a lot of deep research into the meaning of the songs, it’s fine.
In this case, the author seems to have pulled lyric meaning from what was painfully obvious, what was publicly stated about the song by the band in the past, or speculation. There isn’t an attempt to get a hold of the song writers for any clarity just for the purpose of this book.
But that’s OK. This fits the bill for what I need some nights.
They’ve supposedly got books coming later this year about Journey, Deep Purple (from 1984 on) and Steven Wilson (solo) and I’m looking forward to those. (For Journey, I picture a lot of cut/paste of “It’s a love song focused on...” or “It’s a breakup song focused on...”.)