blue.monk
1K Club - QQ Shooting Star
Frank Zappa Wind Ensemble; SACD
3.1 mix listed as 5.1. Not great, no punch, no bottom end. For collector's only really.
Being an FZ completist and a huge Opus 3 fan, I popped for this. Your review is right on the money.
Different strokes, of course. I love this disc. No, it does not employ a pop-like discrete surround approach but rather a 'classical' one, placing you in the middle of the performance space. From the technical info:
The Blumien single-point source stereo recording technique employed since Opus 3's inception means that the acoustic information for the rear channels, i.e. the "surround sound", is available - The centre and sub-woofer have not been utilized on this disc.
I think the sound is wonderful with plenty of 'bottom end and punch'. Perhaps the the absence of a sub-woofer track would dilute the impact on some setups? The arrangements and performances are top-notch. Delightfully clever and often quirky interpretations of Zappa's music.