I will buy this set and the blu ray is the highlight for sure...BUT..I'm a guy that still enjoys CD's...but they can't be compressed to death like most of the newer versions of some of these titles ....if you look at the versions on this list it isn't very encouragingWhoa ... just read ALL the vitriolic comments on the SDE site regarding this massive box set! Sure, THE WHO'S NEXT with an ATMOS, 5.1 and two Stereo remixes from the original analogue masters is a dream come true by the master himself, Steve Wilson...but really, 10 RBCDs and a 100 page book??????
And will calls for Paul Sinclair to POSSIBLY release a stand alone Pure Audio BD~A ever reach the ears of both Universal and Townsend/Daltrey because in reality, that's ALL most of us really want.
At 6 inches thick, that massive boxset will not only take up a LOT of valuable space but most of us will never play all 10 RBCDs unless we're absolute completists!
BaBa O'Riley ...are you LISTENING?
WHO’S NEXT/LIFEHOUSE Box set coming in September 2023 (STEVEN WILSON DOLBY ATMOS & 5.1 MIXES CONFIRMED!!)
- Thread starter Tres Discrete
- Start date
Help Support QuadraphonicQuad:
I'd be MUCH more likely to pay $100 just for the blu-ray than $300+ for the additional crap I don't want or need.
I wonder if the "powers that be" would consider differently if they thought they could sell the blu-ray for that price? $100 bucks for a blu-ray in a regular, unadorned standard case, is one hell of a profit margin per unit.
I wonder if the "powers that be" would consider differently if they thought they could sell the blu-ray for that price? $100 bucks for a blu-ray in a regular, unadorned standard case, is one hell of a profit margin per unit.
Bill
you are setting the bar too high !!
50 dollars is what I say which is STILL a huge profit margin for the label
I am of that certain age and I can afford it but not that long ago we would get the surround mix on blu ray for around $20. These $100 - $200 - $300 dollar boxes loaded with filler is ridiculous. Come next yr., will people on this forum think $400 - $500 is reasonable because it’s a classic album. This is pure price gouging and as I previously said, I believe this will make people think more about streaming Dolby Atmos music mixes. I refuse to be ripped off JMHO
- Joined
- Jan 9, 2013
- Messages
- 25,686
Depending on the amount of pre~orders and actual sales at time of release, I really think UMG/the WHO camp will determine whether an eventual stand alone BD~A is in the cards. Sales~wise, it would be foolish to advertise an eventual stand alone BD~A, but that doesn't mean it will be ruled out.
Unless you HAVE to be the first on the block to own the massive box set, my advice would be to wait.
Whatever goes UP will eventually come DOWN!
Heck, we've waited over 50 years for WHO'S NEXT to be released in surround .... what are a few more months?
Imbobman
1K Club - QQ Shooting Star
You aren't going to be dipping into your Super bowl ticket funds, are you?
At this price, I wouldn't call this a bargain, the best I ever had
Last edited:
Can I please ask that we refrain from the "I'm not buying this; it's too expensive; I just want the Blu-Ray" comments in this thread?
I am well aware that not everyone can afford a box set as costly as this one.
However this is one of the most important albums of the last 50+ years that so many of us have wanted in surround sound for a very long time, and now it's finally happening.
Not only that but with Steven Wilson remixing this one, it pretty much means this will be the definitive way to hear the album from here on out.
Plus there's 14 additional tracks also remixed in surround sound as well. Even if @PaulatSDE had managed to get an SDE single-disc Blu-Ray released, it would likely only contain the proper album and none of these additional tracks, so it's really like we're getting 2+ albums worth of material in surround sound on this disc.
Also there's no vinyl at all in this set and with the huge amount of CDs included and the amount of content on each disc, it certainly looks like this set was put together by people who really wanted to provide us with the maximum amount of content available. No skimping on content for this set. Compare the price of this set to the more skimpy sets from RUSH and Pink Floyd and you can at least say that this one is more deserving of this high price tag than any of those others.
Finally, a Blu-Ray in a costly box set is better than no Blu-Ray at all (still pissed at the Beatles for the Revolver set...)
So buy it or don't buy it, and if you don't buy it, you can probably stream the Atmos mix on Atmos streaming providers.
Just cool it on all the negative comments, thanks!
I am well aware that not everyone can afford a box set as costly as this one.
However this is one of the most important albums of the last 50+ years that so many of us have wanted in surround sound for a very long time, and now it's finally happening.
Not only that but with Steven Wilson remixing this one, it pretty much means this will be the definitive way to hear the album from here on out.
Plus there's 14 additional tracks also remixed in surround sound as well. Even if @PaulatSDE had managed to get an SDE single-disc Blu-Ray released, it would likely only contain the proper album and none of these additional tracks, so it's really like we're getting 2+ albums worth of material in surround sound on this disc.
Also there's no vinyl at all in this set and with the huge amount of CDs included and the amount of content on each disc, it certainly looks like this set was put together by people who really wanted to provide us with the maximum amount of content available. No skimping on content for this set. Compare the price of this set to the more skimpy sets from RUSH and Pink Floyd and you can at least say that this one is more deserving of this high price tag than any of those others.
Finally, a Blu-Ray in a costly box set is better than no Blu-Ray at all (still pissed at the Beatles for the Revolver set...)
So buy it or don't buy it, and if you don't buy it, you can probably stream the Atmos mix on Atmos streaming providers.
Just cool it on all the negative comments, thanks!
tarkusnj
400 Club - QQ All-Star
That's just sickening...300 bucksPlease…a surround mix…I’m begging
https://superdeluxeedition.com/news/pete-towshend-confirms-whos-next-reissue-for-2022/
Addendum: sorry rt, I posted this before i saw your post above.
Last edited:
New cover photo on the band's Facebook page.
Who wants to be the one to tell them that the 50th anniversary was two years ago?
Who wants to be the one to tell them that the 50th anniversary was two years ago?
Shoot. didn't.
New cover photo on the band's Facebook page.
View attachment 93949
Who wants to be the one to tell them that the 50th anniversary was two years ago?
Consider it a delayed post Pandemic celebration
This is "THE BIG ONE", a once in a generational release folks, like DSOTM and Abbey Road, and we are here to enjoy it!
*Don't pee your panties (or boxers), because the beer's a little pricey!
I admit I have loved my Aug 10, 2010 (reissue) Stereo SHM SACD for a long time, going to listen now and say goodbye ol friend.
- Joined
- Jan 9, 2013
- Messages
- 25,686
DITTO, Markie and ironically, it was the very first Stereo single layer SHM~SACD I ever purchased ...and at the time it was $60!
My first "green disc" SHM-SACD was Aja and it too was $60
That this is a seminal album with lots of extras is amazing.
I'll have to wait and see.
I'll have to wait and see.
As @Clint Eastwood might say, the Who box set costs a fistful of dollars. Add in the t shirt for a few dollars more.
- Joined
- Jan 9, 2013
- Messages
- 25,686
The current price of new Stereo SHM~SACDs is now about $22 ........I currently have 2 on pre~order with CDJapan! But the packaging is not nearly as elaborate as with those early SHM~SACD releases!
Typo on their part, according to Steven's Facebook post both the stereo & 5.1 remixes are 96/24.
right, thanks, even better
Similar threads
- Poll
- Sticky
- Poll
Latest posts
-
-
-
HiRez Poll Doobie Brothers, The - TOULOUSE STREET [Blu-Ray Audio]- Latest: Michael Marshall
