I feel like their bad songs are unlistenable (Radio song) but their good ones are so so good. Of course it's subjective but I can't think of a band with such extremes, for me.
I used to despise Radio Song too. These days I think it actually works quite well. Shiny Happy People on the other hand… If it weren't for that one clunker, this would be a near perfect album. Country Feedback, Half a World Away, Near Wild Heaven and Losing My Religion are among the best they've done IMO.