Flaming Lips Yoshimi Atmos Blu-ray out November 1st, 2024!

[sukothai]

I've seen some people mention that here and I really really don't get it. There are a trove of 5.1 mixes mastered with more compression than Yoshimi, including ones from Beck, Seal, Elton John, and even the Flaming Lips themselves. If something is grinding your ears about Yoshimi's 5.1 mix, I really don't think it's the mastering compression, because most recordings since the late 90s should be flat-out unlistenable to you if that were the case.

It is subtle, but look at the DR numbers to see what I mean. The 5.1 has all of the peaks pushed up to 0; the Atmos is much more dynamic with RMS levels nearly half that of the 5.1. I do have a hard time listening to most everything since the late 90's at any significant volume level, though surround tends to be less DR compressed. DR compression has a place, but not at higher volume with five to nine full range speakers and a sub.

 

[Dynamic Editor]

It is subtle, but look at the DR numbers to see what I mean. The 5.1 has all of the peaks pushed up to 0; the Atmos is much more dynamic with RMS levels nearly half that of the 5.1. I do have a hard time listening to most everything since the late 90's at any significant volume level, though surround tends to be less DR compressed. DR compression has a place, but not at higher volume with five to nine full range speakers and a sub.

Oh yeah, I didn't think it was necessary, I just question how perceptible it is when it comes to the actual result of the mastering compression itself, as opposed to being confirmation bias or due to some other factor in the sound.

 

[himey]

Oh yeah, I didn't think it was necessary, I just question how perceptible it is when it comes to the actual result of the mastering compression itself, as opposed to being confirmation bias or due to some other factor in the sound.

You don't think there is a difference in the dynamics of the 5.1 Yoshimi vs Sea Change?

 

[Dynamic Editor]

You don't think there is a difference in the dynamics of the 5.1 Yoshimi vs Sea Change?

Not really much of any as a result of mastering.

Again, there is discussion to be had of dynamics in music, but if the 5.1 of Yoshimi is fatiguing to you, the mastering compression is not what's to blame.

 

[sukothai]

Yeah, some songs aren't too bad. Take a look at "Yoshimi Battles the Pink Robots pt.1" for an example of one that is fatiguing :

5.1 Front L/R:

Atmos (7.1) Front L/R:

 

[J. PUPSTER]

Someone named failedmuso put it up on discogs.

https://www.discogs.com/release/32178321-The-Flaming-Lips-Yoshimi-Battles-The-Pink-Robots

I'm liking the overall sound and mix in the Atmos 7.1

 

[Thonolan]

I have never listened to a single note of this band's music but, very much NOT in my style, I've impulsively ordered this from Amazon in Spain as I saw it cheap (17 €). I'm a huge fan of Elliot Scheiner mixing style and, judging by the comments, the Atmos mix (not by him) seems to be great too. Normally I like psychedelic rock so I think there's a decent chance I won't end up returning this!

 

[tlake6659]

What's the dialog norm values for the DTS 5.1 and the Atmos mixes?

 

[sukothai]

What's the dialog norm values for the DTS 5.1 and the Atmos mixes?

The DTS 5.1 is -12dB:

>> M2TS, 1 video track, 1 audio track, 0:49:02, 60i /1.001 (11 chapters)
> 3: DTS Master Audio, English, 5.1 channels, 24 bits, 96kHz, dialnorm: -12dB

But AudioMuxer doesn't show dialog norm for the Atmos:

>> M2TS, 1 video track, 1 audio track, 0:47:33, 60i /1.001 (11 chapters)
> 3: TrueHD/AC3 (Atmos), English, 7.1 channels, 48kHz


I'm not sure if this means it is at the default -31dB (meaning it is disabled) or what.

 

[tlake6659]

The DTS 5.1 is -12dB:

>> M2TS, 1 video track, 1 audio track, 0:49:02, 60i /1.001 (11 chapters)
> 3: DTS Master Audio, English, 5.1 channels, 24 bits, 96kHz, dialnorm: -12dB

But AudioMuxer doesn't show dialog norm for the Atmos:

>> M2TS, 1 video track, 1 audio track, 0:47:33, 60i /1.001 (11 chapters)
> 3: TrueHD/AC3 (Atmos), English, 7.1 channels, 48kHz


I'm not sure if this means it is at the default -31dB (meaning it is disabled) or what.

Thanks, now I know why the Blu-ray 5.1 mix is so much quieter than the DVD-A 5.1 mix.

 

[marpow]

Someone named failedmuso put it up on discogs.

He did a great job, good pictures, actual release date and all the rest.

 

[Mesozoic Mike]

I wish I could listen to this disc with my TV off. Very annoying visuals, but if I turn my TV off, the audio briefly cuts out every 10 seconds or so.

 

[4-earredwonder]

I wish I could listen to this disc with my TV off. Very annoying visuals, but if I turn my TV off, the audio briefly cuts out every 10 seconds or so.

Mike, just engage the PURE AUDIO button on your remote and it will turn off the video portion and let the music play uninterrupted.

 

[Thonolan]

I wish I could listen to this disc with my TV off. Very annoying visuals, but if I turn my TV off, the audio briefly cuts out every 10 seconds or so.

I suppose it isn't an LG OLED TV, is it? These have the option of easily turning off the screen without turning off the device. That's why I do when I don't want to see the visuals, since the pure audio button of the remote also turns off the blu-ray player's screen, and I enjoy having that one on for track number, elapsed time etc.

 

[svengaleekie]

I should have had mine delivered this morning but good old Royal Mail sailed past me in the night and took it to Fishguard, 55 miles too far West, hopefully they will sort it out and I'll get it tomorrow.

 

[svtmike]

Got mine Saturday, listening to the 7.1 today in my car on my way to/from the office. If the second half lives up to the first, another 10 is coming in the poll thread...

 

[beerking]

Mine arrived today from SDE

Firstly, I can't watch the graphics!! They are sending me into a deep trance....the wife said she can't see the difference

And on to the music
This is an Atmos Mix that knocks the original 5.1 into history (I have it)
Sooo much going on.

 

[jefe1]

Oh no, Im going to have to buy this one too.......and I have their three DVDAs.

 

[edisonbaggins]

Very much looking forward to cranking this BD Atmos mix soon. I already love the streaming version.

 

[ssully]

Amused at complaints about this having too much dynamic range -- their old DVDAs being smashed pretty adroitly, which was part of their sound.

It'll maybe be awhile before I get around to buying the BluRay because I recently listened to the whole album again and decided, you know what? It's kind of boring.