Porcupine Tree - Closure / Continuation (5.1/Dolby Atmos) 24-Jun-2022

QuadraphonicQuad

Help Support QuadraphonicQuad:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Saw the show in Philly this weekend. The 2 guys I went with were not huge fans, but after the show they both commented how amazing the show was even thought they only knew a few songs. Band was on fire, a great show worth going to if you have the opportunity.
 
This has really dropped in price...40 quid!!

Closure / Continuation Closure / Continuation: Amazon.co.uk: CDs & Vinyl
This makes 62$CDN + 26$CDN shipping for me, for a total of 88$CDN. Similar to the 83$CDN (63$USD) I paid for mine from ImportCDs. Still better than my local record store (104$CDN). Maybe they want to get rid of it? Amazon often does this when they want to get rid of an item. Amazon Canada did it for Rush - AFTK, but it was still too much for me. I should have bought it and sold the vinyls.
 
Deluxe Packaging/Content: 1
The cardboard slot disc packaging and the softbound book with obscured photos and very little info simply exudes cheapness. But the nearly empty blu-ray is the worst aspect of this so-called "deluxe" package, especially for the premium price. Not including the 3 bonus tracks, or instrumentals, or videos, or any of the AIR Studio sessions material on the blu-ray is deeply disappointing and breaks sharply with previous PT deluxe release precedent.

About the Deluxe Packaging/Content: 1
The problem lies I think they signed by Music for Nations, (Sony) they have a good deal with them, but customers not. If you compare what you get by Snapper music ( Kscope, Transmission etc) was always with lot of extras; also on the dvda as blu rays.
Same with CC live absolute no extra's on the blu ray in the normal version.
Completely agree. In the past, whenever I bought PT or SW albums, it always felt as if Wilson wanted to please his listeners with the extra content and quality packaging. I really liked that. There was a sense of generosity and respect for his listeners. Now it feels like a meanness has set in and a wish to make as much money while he can. A minimal amount of 'product' released for the maximum money you can get away with. He has become what he was parodying. Perhaps he was flagging this intention on Future Bites. :(
 
Last edited:
So what's your explanation for the standalone releases of The Harmony Codex and C/C Live album?
Yes, nice to still have standard bluray releases. And obviously the music remains wonderful. The discussion was about the special releases, those wonderful deluxe editions we used to get. :)
 
Last edited:
Completely agree. In the past, whenever I bought PT or SW albums, it always felt as if Wilson wanted to please his listeners with the extra content and quality packaging. I really liked that. There was a sense of generosity and respect for his listeners. Now it feels like a meanness has set in and a wish to make as much money while he can. A minimal amount of 'product' released for the maximum money you can get away with. He has become what he was parodying. Perhaps he was flagging this intention on Future Bites. :(
I took TFB as being cynical. I suspect your last statement is actually true. Or that there is much truth in it.
 
He has become what he was parodying. Perhaps he was flagging this intention on Future Bites.
The Future Bites was very intentionally intended to be a satirical sendup of consumerism. He covers this in his book. He literally sold items like toilet paper, a can of air, etc. on his website just to prove a point.
 
The Future Bites was very intentionally intended to be a satirical sendup of consumerism. He covers this in his book. He literally sold items like toilet paper, a can of air, etc. on his website just to prove a point.
One is not required to take everything the man says or writes at face value.
If he donated the proceeds from the sales of all that crap to charity, then I wouldn’t suspect cynicism, at all. And maybe he did, but sure haven’t heard about it. As it is, it still comes off as cynical fleecing of the fans, to me. And apparently to others.
 
The Future Bites was very intentionally intended to be a satirical sendup of consumerism. He covers this in his book. He literally sold items like toilet paper, a can of air, etc. on his website just to prove a point.
Indeed, and I'm not sure why some fans are so desperate to paint him in a negative light for this. Perhaps bitterness about the change in musical direction?
 
I find his latest snooze worthy but it is his muse and I have no right to judge his direction; only what I think of it.
That said, is it really satire if you are selling that stuff to your own fans?
 
I find his latest snooze worthy but it is his muse and I have no right to judge his direction; only what I think of it.
That said, is it really satire if you are selling that stuff to your own fans?
I can't say for certain if he made money off the toilet paper proceeds (lol), but he also sold a "limited edition of one" box set for (I think) $10,000 as part of this, and he stated specifically that he donated that to charity. I think of the whole concept as being part of the performance art aspect of the project. Most of his albums are surrounded by some sort of higher concept, he isn't just interested in the audio aspects but rather the audio/visual/storytelling aspect taken as a whole.
 
Back
Top