I'm surprised no-one's expressed an interest in this.. its cheap, it's all over eBay right now, its legit, its a limited edition promo (so get it while it lasts!), its Bang & Olufsen-related (basically its gonna be of a certain standard), its blu-ray audio, its surround sound... bit of a no-brainer for QQ members imho
It is all the things you say, but it is also the soundtrack to
Les Miserables, and frankly I wouldn't wish to risk anyone finding me with a copy of that lying around the apartment. Your dedication to all things hi-res surround is admirable, Fred.
Bang & Olufsen make high-end lifestyle systems for wealthy buyers who care far more about styling than audio quality, so I'm not sure that their involvement is a seal of much audiophile value, but I am curious - what exactly is their involvement?
I finally found the Dolby PLII Music setting over the weekend (it was in my amp's standard settings, and I had previously been looking under advanced concert), and had some fun with it. It was barely effective at all on
Breakfast in America, very good on
Legend and most impressive by far on
Songs In the Key of Life. I don't know why the effect was so different across those three BD-As, but it was amazing what it conjured up from a 2-channel source.
It did not, however, really sound much like discreet 5.1 to me. In spreading the sound around the speakers by whatever algorithm it uses, it produced a slightly unfocused effect, in some ways diluting the sound quality. Sometimes I'd switch back to stereo and find the music far more powerful, something I admit unwillingly as a surround devotee. It's certainly an interesting option and an impressive trick, but we really do need some proper 5.1 mixes in this new format.
As for Amazon being cheaper than the HFPA store, that's a given. They forcibly undercut everyone - a £20 book on its own publisher's website will be £10 on Amazon on the day of release - and I've never seen a proprietary shop that offered its wares for as little as the prices Amazon force them to accept (with promises of scale).