I've ordered this as well. I notice the label shown on Amazon.ca indicates Dolby Atmos, but presumably this is wrong.
Louise Patricia Crane - Netherworld 5.1 DVD-V/CD (featuring Jakko Jakszyk/Mel Collins/Tony Levin/Ian Anderson)
- Thread starter surroundedbymusic
- Start date
Help Support QuadraphonicQuad:
MODS
Can we have a Poll for this outstanding release, please.
Can we have a Poll for this outstanding release, please.
Last edited:
silversundial
New member
Wouldn't read much in to it. I imagine graphics / designs and "mock ups" can differ from final products and can be made at different times, leading to discrepancies like this. The description never claims Atmos on the Storybook, so I gather that's simply what has happened here. Either way, stunning release, which keeps revealing more beauty with each new listen (listening again now).
May be the cost of producing a Blu-ray was too high?
- Joined
- Jan 9, 2013
- Messages
- 25,293
But a DVD with LOSSLESS LPCM 5.1/Stereo would've been a better option and there're NO further royalty payments to utilize LPCM!!!!!!
True, but no supported commercial software to do it anymore
As has been stated time and time (and time) again: DVD-V does not support 5.1 PCM.
I’ve approached them about doing a hi-res download through IAA, but no reply as yet.
JediJoker
Audio Engineer/Enthusiast
Not true. It is within spec. I have, however, never encountered a DVD-V with LPCM beyond 2.0.
silversundial
New member
Newbie here, is the poll a vote of appreciation for this glorious release? (It will get my vote!)
Have enjoyed several full length listens now, ale in hand. It certainly is a true album experience she has crafted, best heard as a body of work in one sitting. I see she wrote a nice backstory on composing one of my favourite songs so far, Spirit Of The Forest.
What a seductively beautiful voice Ms Crane has. a siren song.
Attachments
Hmmm, my CD + DVD order from Amazon.ca has been delayed, and it's no longer listed on their site. I assume this is because the demand for it was higher than expected, which is good news, and they're waiting for more stock.
Or they never got any in. I've had this situation with Amazon.ca before where they take forever and eventually cancel your order. I've cancelled and ordered elsewhere for a few dollars more.
They're still available via bandcamp, so amazon.ca has no excuses
Okay, am I seeing this right? Only option seems to be $46 to the US from Bandcamp?
Not sure, honestly. CC Music has it listed as backordered, with an ETA of early September. $24 and some change.
https://www.ccmusic.com/netherworld/803341602656
- Joined
- Jan 9, 2013
- Messages
- 25,293
I haven't had the opportunity to listen to the 5.1 mix yet (had to dismantle my former, semi-dedicated 5.1 room before my new, fully dedicated Atmos room is complete, so only stereo listening for the time being). I do like the album in stereo, there are some outstanding moments and I can see the potential for a much more engaging experience in surround, but the real revelation has been Deep Blue. I've been streaming it and I find it truly amazing. It's certainly different.
silversundial
New member
Having binged both Netherworld (the multichannel mix and the stereo mix when travelling or driving) and Deep Blue consistently recently, I feel there's no contest. Netherworld is to my mind a much more rewarding experience as a complete album, her songwriting much more honed, mature and a more fully fleshed body of work with excellent songcraft. I noticed the audio quality tends to be very noticeably different too from its predecessor. Deep Blue at times I'm struggling to hear the clarity of Louise's beautiful voice, the subtle nuances that (comparing it to Netherworld) get lost in all the many effects that are being used on the vocals. I think Deep Blue has some great moments (the title track, Cascading are stellar cuts!) but for me her upwards trajectory from it to Netherworld, is stark. Might be a slower burn for some, but I believe Netherworld will come to be regarded as her masterpiece. Keen to see where she goes next.
Similar threads
